Figuring out when to hire employees is a challenge. It’s even harder amid ever-shifting market dynamics. But workforce planning is a challenge every organization must tackle head-on, or risk misallocating resources, decelerating pipelines, and missing opportunities.

Brightwing has 50-plus years of hiring and workforce planning under our belt. Our experience runs the gamut from engineering to operations to finance and other high-skill industries. From that experience, here are some tips for figuring out when to time your employee hires. 

What is workforce planning?

Workforce planning is the strategic process of ensuring you have the personnel needed to meet your business goals and plans. Essentially, it’s the approach you use to figure out when to hire employees for your business.

This graphic illustrates many of the key stages of workforce planning, including strategic planning, workforce analysis, gap analysis, and execution. 

Workforce Planning Model

Image source: Monday.com

Top mistakes people make when timing employee hires

According to a recent report from Harvard Business Review Analytic Services, 73% of business leaders claim to have missed key objectives due to poor workforce planning. This isn’t surprising. Workforce planning is a complex process, and it’s easy to get it wrong. 

In our experience, here are some of the most common mistakes organizations make when hiring new engineers, IT professionals, operations managers, and other high-skill talent. 

Hiring too quickly

At the first uptick in growth, many leaders jump the gun and want to hire as fast as possible. While the motivation is understandable, hiring too quickly presents several risks:

  • Increased likelihood of a bad hire, which not only hurts your organizational performance, but you have to pay to replace them
  • Decreased team morale, as you add the wrong people onto the team
  • Failure to verify whether the business can support the new hire and whether they’re a value-add

 

Hiring too slowly

On the other hand, being too perfectionist and methodical in your hiring processes—or lacking internal recruiting resources—comes with its own risks:

  • Missed business opportunities and projects because you didn’t have the team to support them
  • Decreased team morale as they’re missing deadlines and working overtime
  • Dissatisfied customers as you fail to meet their expectations
  • Negative work environment may cause you to lose the top talent you already have

 

Only pursuing active job seekers

If you’re only pursuing active job seekers, you’re missing out on over two-thirds of the job market, according to data from LinkedIn

What’s more, top performers are only in the job market for a short period of time. While the number varies depending on which source you view, most top performers are on the market for as few as 10 days. 

This makes sense. Top performers don’t have to spend months on end or submit hundreds of resumés to get interviews and offers. Their record, network, and experience speak for themselves.

And while some top performers may currently be in-market, many aren’t. Targeting only active job seekers means you’re going after a small percentage of top performers, and you might miss out on someone who’s an excellent fit for the role. 

Not hiring for soft skills or cultural fit

Yes, it’s important to hire for hard skills. No question. But hard skills alone don’t translate to team synergy. To do that, you need a combination of soft skills and cultural fit. Failure to consider these factors increases your chances of internal friction post-hire. 

Top signs it’s time to hire more employees

The key to success in workforce planning and expansion is timing. You want to hit the Goldilocks zone: not too quickly, not too slowly. So as you go about your workforce planning initiatives, here are clear signs it’s time to make it a priority. 

1. Missed project deadlines

If you have a team filled with high performers but your projects are consistently behind schedule, that’s a sure sign you don’t have enough people on board. Missing deadlines not only hurts internal team morale, but erodes client trust and stymies future growth potential. 

2. Employee burnout

Among the high-value talent that Brightwing places, burnout is far more common than it should be. 46% of engineers report team-wide burnout (only 34% of executives reported the same). 40% of tech workers are overworked to the point of burnout

While overwork is one cause of burnout, poor culture and employee experience also contribute to it. So hiring more employees without considering culture and soft skills may do more harm than good. Keep this in mind when planning out your workforce.  

3. Ambitious growth goals

If your organization has ambitious growth goals—significantly above and beyond what you’ve accomplished in the past—you’ll likely exceed your current team capacity. A mandate for growth means a mandate to hire more employees. Otherwise, your sales pipelines will start to bottleneck quickly. 

According to Brightwing President Jeff Genovich, “When your growth goals exceed your team capacity, that’s a sure-fire sign you need to find outside help. A staffing partner can help you identify who to bring in, then will go out and find those people for you.” 

4. Accelerating sales pipelines

Once your sales pipelines start to accelerate, that’s a surefire sign you need to hire more employees. Otherwise, you won’t be able to service all that new business you just attracted. 

The problem is that as quickly as sales accelerate, they could very well decelerate. Obviously we’d prefer sales to keep on growing. But market downturns, sudden customer churn, and other factors can cause unexpected losses. You need to hedge against those risks. 

That’s one reason why many organizations will hire contractors for short-term projects. If sales keep coming in, you can rehire those contractors. And if they don’t, you’re not saddled with a team your business can’t support. 

“A popular option among our candidates is contract-to-hire,” says Genovich. “When expenses are tight, people want to reduce their risk of sales pipeline misses. Or, adopt a fractional recruiting model to hire talent at the scale of a recruiting firm without the typical expense.” 

FAQs on hiring employees

What are the warning signs of a disgruntled employee?

Disgruntled employees often give clear warning signs and red flags. These include vocal complaints, chronic exhaustion, poor attendance, frequent absences and tardiness, and more. 

How can you tell if an employee isn’t a good fit? 

If you have a strong company culture, it’s easy to tell if an employee isn’t a good fit—especially within the first 90 days. New employees should come out the gate hot and showcase their best habits early and often. 

Key warning signs include performance issues, lack of alignment with company values, negative impact on team morale, and unhappiness during work. 

What are the four stages of workforce planning?

The four stages of workforce planning include: 1) analyzing your current workforce, 2) determining your strategic business goals and the workforce needed to support them, 3) identifying gaps, and 4) developing talent acquisition strategies to close those gaps. 

Final thoughts on when to hire employees

Figuring out when to hire employees is a tough game. There’s certainly an element of risk involved. That’s why it’s a good idea to run your workforce planning strategies by someone who has extensive experience and knows all the mistakes to avoid. 

Brightwing’s hiring process is strategic in nature. We not only hunt down candidates, but help you figure out what talent you need and when. So if you’re struggling to time employee expansion right, consider partnering with us and we’ll help ensure your success.